
The Pajaro Valley Unified School District Board of Trustees on Wednesday selected a national consulting firm to lead the search for its next superintendent, following a discussion about community involvement, transparency and whether the district should prioritize internal candidates.
The board selected McPherson & Jacobson, a Nebraska-based firm that specializes in superintendent recruitment, at a cost not to exceed $28,200.
Trustee Gabriel Medina abstained from the vote, and Trustee Daniel Dodge Jr. was absent.
The district is searching for a replacement for Superintendent Heather Contreras, who is leaving to lead San Luis Coastal Unified School District beginning July 1, 2027.
Founded in 1991, McPherson & Jacobson says it has conducted more than 1,100 superintendent searches nationwide. The firm has consultants in 45 states and has conducted 19 superintendent searches in California since 2018.
The PVUSD search will be led by Nicole Anderson of Vallejo and Daniel Moirao of Danville.
The company proposes a roughly 12-week process that includes community surveys, public meetings, recruitment, candidate screening, background checks and interviews. The firm also provides assistance during the new superintendent’s transition into the position.
During Wednesday’s discussion, Medina questioned why the district should spend money on a search firm before considering qualified candidates already working in PVUSD.
“The people that gave me feedback said, why are we spending money on this when we could hire from the inside and look at the internal candidates as a board, which is our duty,” he said.
Medina proposed amending the agreement to require the firm to consider internal applicants before expanding the search outside the district.
His motion failed for lack of a second.
Medina also expressed concern that selecting a firm before newly elected trustees take office could limit their ability to shape the process.
Trustee Joy Flynn said the incoming board would establish the search criteria and provide direction to the consultants.
“But the contract has its boundaries and its scaffolding, but it’s gonna be built based on what it is we want with their experience and expertise,” Flynn said.
She added that local candidates should be seriously considered, but that the district should not limit its search to the Pajaro Valley.
“I think that just because somebody isn’t from here doesn’t mean they can’t get it done here,” she said.
Flynn said McPherson & Jacobson stood out among the three firms considered because of its Bay Area connections and experience gathering community input.
She also said the firm was willing to explore ways to involve community members in candidate interviews while protecting applicants’ confidentiality, although that might not be possible in every case.
Trustee Olivia Flores emphasized that superintendent searches require confidentiality because applicants may currently hold leadership positions in other districts.
“We can’t just put out whoever applies, put out resumes, and say, what do you think?” she said. “It’s very confidential.”
Flores said a professional search firm could help the incoming board navigate the hiring process while gathering feedback from the community.
Student Trustee Natalie Allen called for multiple town halls, a clear timeline and more information about the candidates and confidentiality requirements.
She said explaining the process would help ensure that the public does not believe the district is withholding information.
Board President Carol Turley said some portions of the search process, including developing interview questions, could require special board meetings.
Trustee Misty Navarro said the district needs an experienced leader capable of addressing its financial problems, educational inequities and labor relations.
“I think it’s important to cast a wide net because this is a very challenging district that is under financial duress,” she said.
Navarro pointed to differences in educational opportunities among district schools, inconsistent bell schedules and the need to work effectively with labor unions.
“We need someone that’s battle-tested and that has good people skills, that has good working relationships with unions, union partners, and that is someone that can connect with the community,” she said.
Watsonville High School social studies teacher Chris Webb urged trustees to consider a less expensive approach before hiring an outside firm.
Webb suggested advertising the position through EdJoin, considering former superintendent Claudia Brogan and turning to McPherson & Jacobson only if those efforts failed to produce a suitable candidate.
“A community committee would be good to get some buy-in,” he said.
Webb also urged trustees to focus on holding district administrators accountable, regardless of who becomes superintendent.
Flynn said the search presents an opportunity for the incoming board to conduct a more inclusive process than in previous years.
“Nothing changes if nothing changes,” she said. “And if we go through this process the same way that it’s been done years past, we’re going to end up in the same situation that we’ve ended up in.”
She urged the next board to consider whether candidates would support the district’s community-developed vision, values and academic goals.
The new superintendent will inherit a district grappling with declining enrollment, budget deficits and staffing reductions, along with ongoing efforts to improve student achievement.
Under McPherson & Jacobson’s proposed schedule, the district could complete the selection process in early 2027, giving the new superintendent time to prepare before Contreras’ departure.










