Two and a half years after taking the helm of Pajaro Valley Unified School District, Superintendent Heather Contreras will be leaving for a new post.
The San Luis Coastal Unified School District Board of Trustees unanimously approved Contreras as its next superintendent Tuesday night. She will begin July 1, 2027, following the retirement of longtime Superintendent Eric Prater.
Contreras’ three-year contract calls for a salary of $323,668 for the 2027-28 school year, along with a $12,000 annual contribution to a supplemental retirement account after she completes her first year.
Her selection drew both praise and concern Tuesday, with SLCUSD trustees pointing to Contreras’ experience navigating PVUSD’s financial and political turmoil as a key qualification, while teachers questioned the hiring process and some aspects of her record in Watsonville.
SLCUSD Trustee Erica Flores Baltodano, an employment attorney, described Contreras as “battle-tested,” both by making unpopular financial decisions and by working in what she characterized as a “hostile work environment.”
“You can make a big fuss about it or you can find other opportunities,” Baltodano said. “So think about what you would do.”
Her comments echoed those of PVUSD Board President Carol Turley, who traveled to San Luis Obispo to support Contreras.
Turley urged the board not to be swayed by what she called the “messaging of an abusive trustee with a vendetta.”
“You can watch our meetings to see how abusive he is to almost every female leader,” Turley said. “Please treasure and care for Dr. Contreras. Our loss is your win.”
Turley was referring to PVUSD Trustee Gabriel Medina, who has frequently clashed with Contreras and other district officials during board meetings.
PVUSD Trustee Olivia Flores also spoke in support of Contreras, saying she had helped improve academic achievement, attendance and graduation rates while confronting the district’s financial problems. Flores described the PVUSD board as “very dysfunctional” and said she often wondered what Contreras could have accomplished with a board, staff and community fully supporting her leadership.
The comments provided an unusually direct glimpse into the board turmoil that has accompanied Contreras’ tenure at PVUSD.
Her departure will come a little more than three years after she took the helm of PVUSD on May 1, 2024.
Contreras began her tenure with what she called a “Look, Listen and Learn” tour, meeting with students, teachers, community members, nonprofit organizations and law enforcement officials to assess the state of the district.
Much of her tenure has since been dominated by PVUSD’s financial challenges, including declining enrollment and the expiration of one-time federal Covid-19 relief funding that had been used to pay employees.
As the district faced millions of dollars in reductions, Contreras oversaw the creation of a 24-member Sustainable Budget Team tasked with examining the district’s finances and recommending cuts.
Those cuts eventually included roughly 100 full-time-equivalent positions.
SLCUSD Board Clerk Brian Clausen said Contreras’ experience making those difficult decisions was one reason she stood out during the search.
“She had to make some really difficult choices that her predecessors did not make,” he said.
But several San Luis Coastal teachers questioned both Contreras’ record and a hiring process they said gave employees little opportunity to learn about her before the vote.
San Luis Coastal Teachers Association President Caroline Cotta pointed to PVUSD’s financial problems, layoffs and a 2025 online petition calling for a vote of no confidence in Contreras. Cotta asked the board to delay its decision so employees and community members could learn more about Contreras.
SLCTA Vice President Kevin Laffin similarly cited PVUSD’s deficit spending, budget reductions and layoffs and questioned whether the board had contacted parents, teachers and labor representatives in Pajaro Valley before making its selection.
Board members defended the search.
Board President Ellen Sheffer said consultants held 37 input sessions with more than 300 participants and received 415 survey responses. The board used that feedback to develop the job description and interview questions before conducting interviews over two days.
Baltodano said finalists were heavily vetted through online research, references and conversations with people candidates had not listed as references. She said board members were aware of the negative news coverage surrounding Contreras before selecting her.
Sheffer and Clausen also spent a day in Pajaro Valley meeting with representatives of the teachers union, parents and trustees before the vote.
Contreras acknowledged those concerns after the vote, abandoning a prepared speech in response to what she had heard during public comment.
“I understand the angst that people would have, and especially seeing things that are online,” she said.
Contreras promised “complete collaboration,” listening and accessibility, telling attendees she would give them her cellphone number and inviting them to contact her “morning, noon and night.”
The move will take Contreras from a district of more than 16,000 students to one less than half that size.
SLCUSD serves roughly 7,800 students in San Luis Obispo County, including San Luis Obispo, Los Osos, Morro Bay and Avila Beach. Unlike PVUSD, which has experienced substantial enrollment declines, San Luis Coastal has seen modest growth in recent years.
The districts also face markedly different financial pictures. PVUSD’s 2025-26 adopted budget projected about $366 million in General Fund revenue and $378 million in expenditures—a roughly $12 million gap. San Luis Coastal projected approximately $145 million in revenue against $141 million in expenditures.
Contreras said she understands the challenge of following Prater after nearly 17 years of leadership and pledged to build on what is already in place.
“I do want to be here for this community,” she said. “And I do want you to feel good about the direction that you’re going.”
“And I promise I will make you proud,” she added.
SLCUSD includes a wide swath of central and coastal San Luis Obispo County. Its boundaries include San Luis Obispo, Morro Bay, Los Osos, Avila Beach and Edna Valley, and extend south into northern Pismo Beach.
